Farmers Show Solidarity with Ralph Shinaberry in Tax Auction
It’s been a long time since I got a letter from the IRS.
I got two.
The first one I expected. It says: “According to our records, you have an
amount due on your income tax” from last year. It then urges me to do
something about it and shows me (in a more precise way than I remember from
past notices of this sort) how they’ve calculated the interest and penalties
so far ($2.66 and $6.73). Enclosed along with this three-page letter are a
copy of a one-sheet “Publication 1” (Your Rights as a
Taxpayer) and an even smaller “Notice 1212” (suggesting that I use
their automated services rather than bother someone on the payroll).
The second letter was unexpected. It tells me that I may have been eligible
for the Earned Income Tax Credit last year and suggests that I may have
erroneously forgotten to file for it. Sounds crazy, but it might be true. I
think I was under the impression that having
(Roth conversion) distributions made me ineligible, but I don’t see anything
about this in the 2009 paperwork. Perhaps I do qualify. That would reduce the
tax I owe by, I dunno, something like $200.
I’d feel pretty dumb to have missed something like this, what with all of my
efforts to find good tax credits and deductions.
Fellow Grocer Gets Bidding On Lien Down To Fractional Part Of Value
Hillsdale, Mich., (AP)
Fellow farmers came to the aid of tax rebel Ralph Shinaberry
and helped him keep his farm in
a tax sale.
“I have no intention of taking possession of the property,” said Herbert
Jessup who was the winning bidder at the auction of the 68-year-old rebel’s
Mr. Jessup was one of about 20 farmers who attended the sale and forced out
other bidders by competing for Mr. Shinaberry’s $22,000 farm which was being
auctioned off in a $310 tax sale.
The bidding continued until payment of the tax would give a lien on
1/264th part of the 250-acre farm.
“I just happen to believe a man should have a little freedom with what he
does with his own property,” explained Jessup.
Could Get Title
If Mr. Shinaberry does not pay his tax by
, Mr. Jessup will get a
deed for the portion of land he won. If another six months elapse and Mr.
Shinaberry still has not paid, Mr. Jessup will get clear title to 1
Mr. Shinaberry’s farm is some 33 miles southeast of this southern Michigan
Mr. Shinaberry has worked his farm for 33 years. He has refused to pay a
government penalty for planting one acre of wheat too much in
, but the tax auction was held to satisfy a
county tax claim against the land.
Mr. Shinaberry also has refused to pay the tax. He contends that if the
government controls his use of his land, then he does not really own it.
“They want to take it over,” he said, “so let them pay their own taxes for
Mr. Shinaberry didn’t show up for the auction. He owns 150 acres which he
operates with his son, Max, 21, but 30 acres is tax-exempt under Michigan’s
veterans’ homestead exemption act. Mr. Shinaberry started his row with the
Federal Government in .
Fights Losing Battle
He said he refused to pay because “I don’t believe the Government can tell me
how much I can grow.” He has fought a losing battle in federal courts thus
far on that score.
Mr. Shinaberry and the Federal Government locked horns on wheat acreage
allotments about the same time that Stanley Yankus, Dowagiac,
Mich., and federal
authorities began a battle on the same issue that ended with Mr. Yankus
selling his farm and moving to
The Hillsdale farmer says that if he loses his farm for taxes or for his
rebellion against paying federal assessments, he’s going to hook a car to a
house trailer he owns and go about the country broadcasting from loudspeakers
to all who will listen, his argument against federal control of what farmers
Shinaberry pulled some other stunts in his day. At one point, the government
fined him for raising wheat on 28 acres when his allowed quota was nine acres.
He refused to pay his fine, the government put a lien on his crop, and so
Shinaberry refused to sell it. Most of it rotted while he pursued in the
courts his right to grow as much wheat as he’d like on his own damn farm, and
the rest he personally delivered to the Agriculture Stabilization Commission along with a bill.