Some historical and global examples of tax resistance → women’s suffrage movements → British women’s suffrage movement → Jessie Murray

The Vote

From the issue of The Vote:

Women’s Tax Resistance League.

Dr. Jessie Murray’s Protest.

On there was a most interesting open air meeting in Upper-street, Islington, when Dr. Jessie Murray, of Endsleigh-street, Tavistock-square, protested against the seizure and public sale of her carriage clock, owing to her refusal to pay Imperial taxes. Mrs. [Margaret] Kineton Parkes and Mrs. Tyson also spoke, and gained the attention of a large crowd by whom the usual resolution was unanimously passed.

Tax Resistance in John Burns’ Borough.

On , Mrs. Beaumont Thomas and Mrs. Sutcliffe had goods sold by public auction, because of their refusal to pay King’s taxes. The sale took place at Warren’s Auction Room, Battersea Rise, and afterwards a procession with banners flying wended its way to Mosbury-road, where a protest meeting was held and a big crowd assembled. Miss Beaumont took the chair, and Mrs. [Anne] Cobden Sanderson and Mrs. Kineton Parkes, of the Tax Resistance League, explained the reasons of tax resistance and answered the questions asked. At the conclusion of the speeches cheers were given for the speakers, and a resolution was carried:

“That this meeting is of opinion that women taxpayers are justified in refusing to pay all Imperial taxes till they have the same control over the national expenditure as male taxpayers possess.”

In the Country.

On , goods belonging to Miss Rose were sold at Frinton-on-Sea, owing to her refusal to pay Imperial taxes.


The Vote

From the issue of The Vote:

In Memoriam.

Jessie Margaret Murray, M.B., B.S.Durh.

It is with deep regret that we have to record the death, after a long and painful illness, of Dr. Jessie Murray. All our members and friends who knew Dr. Murray by hearing her speak at protest meetings in Hyde Park and elsewhere, after her Tax Resistance Sales, or as her friends and patients, experienced her sympathetic kindness and infinite pains in bringing cheer and healing, will be grieved to hear of the death of this staunch fighter for women’s freedom.

Of those who took part in the Suffrage struggle some were undoubtedly born fighters, and will spend their lives breaking lances for one case after another. Others had fighting thrust upon them by the conviction that only thus could they be true to principles which they believed to be of vital importance, and Dr. Jessie Murray always gave one the impression of belonging to this class. It was, therefore, not surprising to find her in the ranks of the Tax Resisters, and year after year she was “sold up” because she believed that “taxation without representation is tyranny,” and that to submit to tyranny is to become a consenting party to it. If she was able to do so she always spoke at the Protest Meeting in connection with her sale, and her quiet logical way of stating her case never failed to impress her audience. Dr. Murray studied at the London School of Medicine for Women and Durham University, and qualified in . It was natural that, professionally, she should be attracted by pioneer work, and she was greatly interested in the new psychotherapeutic methods of treating nervous and mental disorders, and here, too, she was a very clear exponent of the views she held. Such women can be ill-spared, but of them all it may be said: “Their works do follow them.” — A Fellow Tax-Resister.


The Vote

From the issue of The Vote:

Tax Resistance.

Sale at Petersfield.

Miss Cummins, who lives in the pretty little district of Froxfield, near Petersfield, had goods sold in respect of non-payment of King’s Taxes on afternoon. Miss [C. Nina] Boyle and Miss [Jessie?] Murray attended the sale from Headquarters, and among local supporters were Miss Cummins and her sister, Mrs. Baddeley (W.S.P.U.), Mr. Powell, Mr. Roper, and others. The assistant auctioneer, to whom it fell to conduct the sale, was most unfriendly, and refused to allow any speaking during the sale; but Miss Boyle was able to shout through a window at his back, just over his shoulder, an announcement that the goods were seized because Miss Cummins refused to submit to taxation without representation, after which quite a number of people who were attending the sale came out to listen to the speeches. Perched on the parapet of the churchyard wall, Miss Murray opened the brief meeting, followed by Miss Boyle, both receiving unexpected attention. Mr. Powell then spoke a few effective words to the men present, calling upon them as voters to give effect to the women’s protest by approaching their member and warning him that Women’s Suffrage was a question to which he would be expected to give serious attention.

It would appear that, in spite of its remote position and quiet, uneventful life, Suffrage has made great way in the Petersfield district. There are some 250 Suffragists, and several influential secessions from the Liberal Association have taken place over the question.

Arrest and Release of Captain Gonne.

Captain Gonne, R.A., was arrested at his residence at Bognor, on , and taken to Lewes gaol for non-payment of Imperial taxes. Captain Gonne, whose wife is a member of the Women’s Tax Resistance League, refuses to pay his wife’s income-tax, because he supports her in the belief that there should be no taxation without representation, and because he wishes to do his share towards altering the iniquitous laws regulating the taxation of married women. He refuses to pay his own taxes as a protest against the Government’s broken pledges to women and their torture of women prisoners. The Women’s Tax Resistance League at once organised a campaign of protest, in which the Women’s Freedom League and other Suffrage societies would have joined, to hold meetings outside Lewes Gaol. On night, however, he was set free; and the Women’s Tax Resistance League is now raising serious points in regard to the legality of the arrest and the treatment otherwise meted out to him. It is well known that Captain Gonne’s health has suffered severely of late, and his serious indisposition is attributable to the excessive violence of Liberal stewards at meetings which Captain Gonne has attended on behalf of the women’s cause.

The following correspondence has been sent us for publication by the Women’s Tax Resistance League:—

To the Home Secretary, Home Office, Whitehall, S.W.

Sir, — Will you kindly inform my committee why, having decided to release Captain Gonne, R.A., from Lewes Jail, you discharged him before it was possible for his family to send for him, as they were prepared to do, rather than expose him in his delicate state of health to a cross-country railway journey unaccompanied?

Did you not state in the House of Commons that prisoners were never released without such necessary precautions having been taken? — Faithfully yours,

(Signed) Margaret Parkes.

To the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Treasury-chambers, Whitehall, S.W.

Sir, — Are you aware of the fact that on evening last Captain Gonne, R.A., was arrested at Bognor for non-payment of Imperial taxes and conveyed to Lewes Jail, and that he was released with no reason given at ? Will you kindly supply the committee immediately with answers to the following questions, as we consider that it is most important to know the reason for such apparently unconstitutional procedure?

  1. By whose authority was Captain Gonne arrested and upon what charge?
  2. Is it not usual in such cases to levy distraint upon the premises in respect of which the taxes are due?
  3. By whose authority were orders sent to the Governor of Lewes Jail for Captain Gonne’s release?
  4. If the imprisonment was a just one, for what reason was he released in less than 48 hours?

Awaiting the favour of your reply. Faithfully yours,

(Signed) Margaret Parkes.

Magistrate Compliments a Woman Tax Resister.

Miss A[gnes Edith] Metcalfe, B.Sc., ex-H.M.I., was summoned at Greenwich Police-court on , for non-payment of dog license. In a short speech she said that she refused on conscientious grounds to pay taxes while women had no vote. The magistrate congratulated Miss Metcalfe on the clearness and eloquence with which she made out her case. He regretted that the law must take its course, and imposed a fine of 7s. with 2s. costs, recoverable by distraint. The alternative was one day’s imprisonment. We would like to contrast this with Miss I[sabelle] Stewart’s case which was identical, but her sentence was £2 fine or fourteen days’ imprisonment.

Also from the same issue:

Women’s Tax Resistance League.

Mrs. [Margaret] Kineton Parkes has just returned from Ireland, where successful public meetings were held in Dublin and Cork, and tax resistance resolutions passed. She attended, as delegate for the Women’s Tax Resistance League, the Suffrage Conference held in Dublin, and spoke upon the present position of Women’s Suffrage. She also took part in the public debate with the National League for Opposing Women’s Suffrage, on which occasion the Suffragists won by a large majority.


The Vote

I’ll finish off this year-long series of this-day-in-The Vote tax resistance history posts with a bit from the issue. You can find a chronological index to the entire series at this link.

Come and protest against the official robbery of married women carried on by the Government for their own benefit. Earl Russell and Mr. [Israel] Zangwill will speak on the subject at the Caxton Hall on The meeting is organised by the Women’s Tax Resistance League.

Women’s Tax Resistance League: A Public Meeting will be held in Caxton Hall, Westminster, on Monday, April 28th, at 8 p.m., to expose the official robbery of married women, and to demand a just amendment of the Income Tax Acts in the new Finance Bill. Chair: Mrs. Cecil Chapman. Speakers: Earl Russell, Israel Zangwill, & others. Tickets (2 shillings, 6 pence reserved, 1 shilling and 6 pence unreserved) may be obtained from the offices of the League, 10, Talbot House, 98, Saint Martin’s-lane, W.C.

Also in the same issue:

Distraint on a Duchess.

Distraint was levied, on , upon the property of [Mary Russell] the Duchess of Bedford in non-payment of Imperial taxes due in respect of the Prince’s Skating Rink, and a silver cup was taken to satisfy the claim. The Duchess has instructed the Women’s Tax Resistance League to point out that this is quite out of order, because as a married woman she is not liable to taxation, and therefore neither assessment nor demand note should have been served upon her, but upon the Duke of Bedford. She, however, allowed the authorities to proceed in this perfectly irregular manner because she wished to use their mistake as an opportunity of making her protest against the treatment of Woman Suffrage by the present Government in the practical way of refusing to pay taxes until women are enfranchised. Her comment is: “Obviously it is not my business to point out the law to those whose duty it should be to understand it.”

Also in the same issue:

Women’s Tax Resistance League…

A quantity of silver, the property of Miss Rhoda Anstey, Principal of the Anstey Physical Training College, Erdington, Warwickshire, was sold on , by public auction, under distraint for King’s taxes. The sale and protest meeting took place in the gymnasium of the college, and the speakers at the meeting were Mrs. [Margaret] Kineton Parkes and Miss Dorothy Evans; Miss Leonora Tyson presided.

On goods, the property of Dr. [Francis] Ede and Dr. [Amy] Sheppard, of Upper Berkeley-street, Portman-square, W., were sold by public auction at 26, Lisson-grove, W.; Dr. Ede made a protest against the sale in the auction rooms. The speakers at the protest meeting which was held after the sale were Miss Amy Hicks, M.A., Dr. Ede, and Mrs. [Anne] Cobden Sanderson.

On , Miss Rose, of Frinton-on-Sea, had goods sold under distraint for King’s taxes, and Miss Amy Hicks, M.A., was the speaker at the protest meeting held in the small Town Hall, Miss Rose being in the chair.

The first tax resistance sale in the Lake District took place on , when Mrs. [Kate Raven] Henry Holiday had goods sold by public auction at Hawks-head, Ambleside. A most enthusiastic protest meeting was held after the sale, the speakers being Mrs. Kineton Parkes and Miss [Winifred] Holiday.

On , goods, the property of Miss Corcoran, were sold at Loughborough by public auction, followed by a successful protest meeting.

Miss Beatrice Harraden’s goods were sold on , at Gill’s Auction Rooms, Cambridge-road, Kilburn. Miss Harraden explained, in the auction room, the reasons for her refusal to pay. At goods belonging to Dr. Mabel Hardie and Miss Gibbs were sold. There was a procession after the sale to public meeting at corner of Harrow-road and Elgin-avenue.

Dr. Jessie Murray’s goods were sold on , at Davies’ Auction Rooms, 15, Upper-street, Islington, and a protest meeting held after sale at Highbury Fields.

On goods of Mrs. Beaumont Thomas and Mrs. Mary Sutcliffe will be sold at Warren’s Auction Room, 73, Battersea Rise (five minutes from Clapham Junction) at Protest meeting after sale. Supporters urgently needed.