Peter J. Reilly has posted a follow-up in his series on war tax resistance
(see ) at his Forbes blog on taxes.
This time he turned the column over to
Ed Agro, and allowed this war tax resister to explain himself.
It’s an interesting article. Agro doesn’t shy away from the grey areas, and
confesses to a lot of uncertainty, ambiguity, and faltering in trying to find
his way to a position on war taxes that works for him.
You get stolen from all year long, and then the opportunity comes for you to
get your share of stolen goods: why shouldn’t you?
Just another way in which government, by endorsing the sociopathic behavior
its agents undertake, contributes to the normalizing of sociopathic behavior
In North Carolina, for nearly three-quarters of the first century of its
settlement the Government was the veriest farce imaginable. During that time
not merely all political authority but all private property in the soil as
well, was vested in the Lords Proprietors, as they were called; yet it was
said that one of them if here “would be regarded no more than a ballad singer
would be.” Under their rule “the people of North Carolina were confessedly
the freest of the free.” Generally speaking, they were sarcastically said to
recognize no authority not derived from themselves and to have deposed their
Governors until they actually thought they had a right so to do. Rebellions,
too, so-called, were the order of the day.
That passage comes from
an address by William
L. Saunders, then the Secretary of State of North Carolina, in
. Saunders had been a commander in Robert E.
Lee’s rebel army, and was a North Carolina patriot. His address sought to
trace the ornery and independence-minded Carolina character back to the
early history of the colony. In the course of this, he includes these
The first outbreak under royal rule was brought about by the attempt of
Governor [Gabriel] Johnston to force the people to bring their rents to the
collectors at places designated by the Government. In this connection it must
be remembered that in those days the people did not own their lands in
fee-simple as we do now, but were tenants and held them upon payment of an
annual rent of so much per hundred acres. Owing to the lack of a sufficient
currency, at a very early day laws were passed making these rents payable in
produce and collectible on the premises. The trouble began in
and several years elapsed before it was
ended. In the year the people thought
forbearance had ceased to be a virtue, and having exhausted all peaceable
means, began to resort to force. In that year, at the General Court at
Edenton, a man was imprisoned for contempt of Court, but the people of Bertie
and Edgecombe, which then covered substantially all the settled territory to
the westward, hearing that he was imprisoned for refusing to deliver his
rents at the appointed places, rose in arms to the number of 500 and marched
on the town, intending to rescue the man by force from the Court, in the
meantime cursing the King and uttering a great many rebellious speeches. When
within five miles of Edenton they learned the truth, and that the man having
made his peace with the Court, had been discharged from custody. The “mob”
thereupon dispersed, threatening, however, “the most cruel usage to such
persons as durst come to demand any rents of them for the future.” This was
the account of the affair the Governor himself gave, to which he added a
declaration of his inability to punish them if they carried out their
threats. The trouble did not end here nor for several years.
In this same Governor Johnston attempted to
deprive the old counties of the province of their immemorial right to send
five delegates each to the Assembly, and issued writs of election for only
two members to the county. The result was that the old counties refused to
regard his writs of election, and when they voted each voter put on his
ballot the names of five men already agreed upon and the sheriffs so
returned. The Legislature thereupon declared the elections void. But the
people would vote in no other way, and in consequence the old counties for
eight years were not represented in the Assembly, and not being represented,
refused to pay taxes or to do any other act that recognized the authority of
the Assembly. The new counties that sent only two members, seeing what the
old ones were doing, said it was not fair to make them bear the whole burden
of the Government, and they, too, refused to pay taxes. And this was the
condition of the Province for eight years, at the end of which time full
representation was restored. And the Governor was powerless to change it.
The next serious trouble grew out of the opposition to the notorious Stamp
Act. This was an act of the British Parliament requiring everything to be
stamped just as has been the case here under the Internal Revenue System. The
stamp masters were seized and forced to swear they would have nothing to do
with the stamps, and it being known when the vessel bringing the stamps would
come up to Wilmington, Colonels Ashe and Waddell, having called out the
militia from Brunswick and the adjoining counties to the number of some 700
men, seized the vessel and held her until her commander promised not to
permit the stamps to be taken from her. Tryon, the new Governor, was a
prisoner in his own house and utterly powerless. Nor was this all. The royal
sloop Viper, then on duty in the river, having
seized several vessels for want of stamped papers, the inhabitants of
Wilmington entered into an agreement not to supply his Majesty’s ships with
provisions until such seizures were stopped; and the boatmen sent for
supplies were put in jail. This agreement was carried out until the
Viper, after being entirely without rations for a
day or two, was driven to terms and stopped her seizures. This was in the
winter of –.
There was neither disguise nor concealment about all this. Everything was
done in the broad open day, by men perfectly well known, and in the very
presence of the Governor, as it were.
Immediately after this period, the
Regulator movement began its
tax resistance campaign in North Carolina. Saunders notes that among the
items on the agenda of the North Carolina rebels during the American
Revolution was the legal rehabilitation of the Regulators, who had been
defeated and forced to sign loyalty oaths.
Find Out More!
For more information on the topic or topics below (organized as “topic →
sub-subtopic”), click on any of the ♦ symbols to see other pages on this site that cover the topic. Or browse the site’s topic index at the “Outline” page.